Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) chairman K Sivan's statement on Saturday that Rs 978 crore Chandrayaan-2 mission was 98 percent success has invited scorn many former senior officials of the space agency.
"In one week (success) percentage has increased by three percent. By the unitary method, in another five days, the success rate will become 100 percent," was the sarcastic comment made by a former official, who did not want to be identified, to
"In two days, the Indian space agency may announce Chandrayaan-2 mission was 100 percent success," another retired ISRO official told
Talking to media persons in Bhubaneswar on Saturday, Sivan had said: "We could not establish any communication with the lander (Vikram) yet. The project was developed in two parts — science and technology demonstration. We achieved total success in science objective while in technology demonstration, the success percentage was almost full. That's why the project can be termed as 98 percent successful."
On September 7, the 1,471 kg Vikram, while on its descent to soft land on the Moon's south polar region, apparently lost control and crash-landed, snapping communication links.
Later the ISRO, in an official statement, said: "The success criteria was defined for each and every phase of the mission and till date 90 to 95 percent of the mission objectives have been accomplished and will continue contribute to lunar science, notwithstanding the loss of communication with the lander."
The Chandrayaan-2 spacecraft comprised three segments — the orbiter (weighing 2,379 kg, eight payloads), 'Vikram' (1,471 kg, four payloads) and 'Pragyan' (27 kg, two payloads).
On July 22, the Rs 978 crore Chandrayaan-2 was launched into the space by India's heavy lift rocket GSLV-Mk III in textbook style.
After five earth-bound orbit raising activities, Chandrayaan-2 was inserted into the lunar orbit. On September 2, Vikram separated from the orbiter.
"A hypothetical but a possible scene — the Orbiter fails after Vikram's separation and the latter safely lands and the rover Pragyan also functioned as planned. So, what will be the success percentage — two?" wondered a former official.
"It was 95 percent a week back. Wait for five more days for 100 percent," he said.
"It is time for the ISRO chief to think, measure and talk. We are being watched by the international media," he added.
Former officials were unanimous in their view that ISRO has to accept the failure, own responsibility, take sincere steps to learn from the failure and identify the remedies first.
"ISRO should use and listen to all possible expertise as it used to do in the past. I am pained to see no signs in this direction," the official added.
Retired officials pointed out to
IANS, that the Chandrayaan-1 mission was termed as 95 percent success as it has fallen short in its life, though scientifically it did more than expected.
"The failure analysis went through for more than a year then. Now claiming 98 percent success for Chandrayaan-2 in the first month itself is not correct," a retired official said.On ISRO's claims that moon landing was a technology demonstrator, he added: "Soft landing by Vikram and in-situ analysis by Pragyan were part of the overall mission objectives."