At a real estate conference in Mumbai recently, Khushru Jijina, the managing director of real estate lending major, Piramal Capital, took the stage to set the tone for the day. He said that whenever he was asked how the real estate sector was doing, his answer was borrowed from yesteryears villain Ajit, who had instructed his henchman to put his enemy in ‘liquid oxygen’ – the rationale being that the liquid wouldn’t let him live, and the oxygen wouldn’t let him die. Jijina said that real estate today was like that unfortunate patient.
Roadblocks for Residential Real Estate
For years now, residential real estate has been in a prolonged slowdown – and every few quarters, there’s some hope of revival or ‘green shoots’, but those hopes quickly die out as unexpected crises emerge – demonetisation, Goods and Services Tax (GST), construction bans, regulatory changes – the real estate sector has seen it all. But in the face of a severe liquidity crunch and apparent slowdown across sectors, things are not looking very good – although you have to take a closer look to see the picture fully.
Residential Real Estate Sales
Let’s take a look at Knight Frank India’s report on residential real estate in the first half of the year. On a year-on-year basis, launches were up 21 percent, which is heartening. Sales were up 4 percent, which isn’t great but is still growing. Unsold inventory levels were down 9 percent, which is good news too. You’d be forgiven for uttering the words ‘green shoot’ again – but look beyond the percentages and things get scary.
Close to 1.30 lakh homes were sold in the first six months of 2019 – but unsold inventory levels are thrice that number, at over 4.50 lakh. What makes things worse is that the average age of these houses is 3 years old – which makes them harder to sell. At current prices and demand trends, it would take over two years to just get rid of all this inventory, without any builder launching even a single project.
But unfortunately, the problems of real estate go beyond just supply and demand – liquidity is a major concern as well. A JLL India report shows that NBFC funding to real estate has nearly halved – going from Rs 52,000 crore in FY18 to Rs 27,000 crore in FY19. The number of fresh loans given to builders was around 1,500 in 2017 – and so far this year, it’s only at 250. With a supply glut, it wouldn’t be the worst thing to not have new launches, right? Well, that’s only part of the problem – Anarock Property Consultants estimates that 1.74 lakh houses worth over Rs 1.7 lakh crore are stalled because of liquidity issues or legal tussles.
What’s more, 66 percent or two-thirds of those homes are sold – which means those many families are simply waiting to take possession of houses that may never see completion. And that trust deficit also makes it difficult for potential homebuyers to put their money into under-construction apartments – which is the basis of the entire real estate business model in the country.
One last data point – on the industry itself. PropEquity estimates that the number of builders in India’s top 9 markets has halved between 2012 and 2018 – going from 3,500 to 1,700. Real estate experts have said that the post-IL&FS consolidation has been worse than post-demonetisation or post-RERA, which means that this number may actually be much lower already. And while this is good for the handful of developers with strong balance sheets, it doesn’t augur too well for homebuyers who may be forced into paying a premium to ensure they get possession on time.
The media has been accused of overplaying the slowdown card, so let’s try and be optimistic for a second. Commercial real estate is doing well, with many cities recording record transaction volumes and values this year. New asset classes like data centres will grow faster as more types of data become confined to India’s geographical boundaries. But residential real estate looks bleak at best for now, and there are no signs that it’s going to get much better any time soon.
Commercial Real Estate