Motilal Oswal
  • SENSEX
    NIFTY 50
Motilal Oswal
Energy

Coal deal showcases lack of transparency in Ukraine

Updated : March 25, 2019 01:41 PM IST

Ukrainian police are investigating two companies and a factory over a coal deal which some anti-corruption campaigners say epitomises the difficulties of doing business in the east European country. The sums involved in the deal are small but the Anti-Corruption Action Centre, an independent watchdog, says it illustrates the lack of transparency in Ukrainian business, an issue in a presidential election on Sunday that has cost President Petro Poroshenko support. State-run coal company Volynvuhillia ordered the Novovolynska-9 mine it oversees in Novovolynsk, northwestern Ukraine, to sell coal to privately held Ukrainskiy Natsionalniy Product (UNP), company documents show. A contract was agreed in December 2017 and sales began two months later. Volodymyr Yurkiv, the mine's director at the time, told Reuters he complained to the energy ministry about the contract because it allowed UNP to pay eight percent less for its coal than the minimum price set by the ministry for private buyers. He and trade unions also protested to the ministry when miners went unpaid as Volynvuhillia spent on other projects and went into the red. Police are now probing Volynvuhillia over the non-payment of 5.9 million hryvnias ($220,000) in salaries from July 15 to September 5, 2018, suspecting unnamed UNP officials of lining their pockets while the miners struggled to make ends meet, according to court documents. Police declined to name the officials. Energy ministry figures show wage arrears in state mines had reached 138.8 million hryvnias by Jan 1.

A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018.(Reuters)
A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018.(Reuters)
A statue to a miner is pictured next to a road in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A statue to a miner is pictured next to a road in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A general view shows the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A general view shows the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners of the Pervomaiska coal mine hold a rally demanding their due wages in a front of the government building in Kiev, Ukraine August 3, 2018. Picture taken August 3, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners of the Pervomaiska coal mine hold a rally demanding their due wages in a front of the government building in Kiev, Ukraine August 3, 2018. Picture taken August 3, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Director of the Novovolynska-9 coal mine Volodymyr Yurkiv speaks to miners underground in the mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Director of the Novovolynska-9 coal mine Volodymyr Yurkiv speaks to miners underground in the mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner loads a cart inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner loads a cart inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Mining engineer Volodymyr Matyukh works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Mining engineer Volodymyr Matyukh works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Mining engineer Volodymyr Matyukh works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018.(Reuters)
Mining engineer Volodymyr Matyukh works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018.(Reuters)
A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Coal is pictured inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Coal is pictured inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners smile while they speak with Reuters after the end of their shift at the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners smile while they speak with Reuters after the end of their shift at the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner looks on as he works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner looks on as he works inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners push a cart inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners push a cart inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners work inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners work inside the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner stands in a corridor after the end of his shift at the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
A miner stands in a corridor after the end of his shift at the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners prepare for their shift at the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Miners prepare for their shift at the Novovolynska-9 coal mine in Novovolynsk, Ukraine August 2, 2018. Picture taken August 2, 2018. (Reuters)
Live TV

Ask Our Experts CNBC TV18

Send your queries on investments and have them answered by our experts

Enter your details

Post